The Beavers led 9-7 in the early going, but the Monks would lead for most of the half, building multiple 11-point advantages, before taking a 40-31 cushion into halftime.
BVU pulled within 44-42 with just over four minutes gone by in the second half and would take its first lead since early in the opening half at 49-48 on a three-point bucket from senior Michael Santich. After the Monks tied it at 49-49 on a free-throw,  Neubaum buried one of his three long range treys to make it 52-49 with 11:14 to play. 
It was back-and-forth over the next few minutes until the Beavers pushed the margin to eight with just under six minutes left. A pair of made free-throws from Neubaum gave BVU its first double-digit advantage of the game with 5:33 to go, and the Beavers would maintain the double-digit margin for the remainder of the lead. Their largest lead came when Neubaum made three of four free-throw attempts in the closing seconds after a pair of technical fouls on the Monks' bench.
Buena Vista is now 4-0 overall and will close out the trip against Elmira College (N.Y.) on Saturday at 3 p.m.