Things turned around quickly for the Beavers, and the team went on to win four straight games and 10 of its final 12 regular season games to finish tied with Wartburg in the standings at 16-8. BVU was the No. 2 seed in the conference tournament but got edged, 5-3, to Wartburg in its first game that snapped the team’s seven-game win streak entering the tournament. It remained alive after slipping past Luther, 7-6, but was eliminated from the tournament after falling 7-3 to Simpson.
The Beavers were forced to sit and wait the remainder of the weekend and see if their 28-15 overall record (16-8 IIAC) was good enough to earn an at-large berth into postseason play. After nearly 48 grueling hours of anticipation, the team learned that the selection committee placed it among the field of the NCAA Central Regional Tournament, and the Beavers made sure to make the most of the opportunity. They traveled to Bloomington, Ill., later that week and leaned on the arm of senior righthander Luke Probasco in what turned out to be a commanding 8-1 victory over Carthage in the opener. That put BVU up against Illinois Wesleyan, who was the host school and the defending NCAA DIII College World Series Champions. That didn’t faze junior lefthander Michael Dirkx, who pitched a complete-game seven-hitter, allowing only one run, as BVU opened many eyes with a 7-1 triumph. After a second straight win over IWU, it set up the championship series rematch against No. 20 Carthage. BVU suffered its first loss of the tournament after a 12-7 defeat in game one but in the winner-take-all game that followed, the Beavers rallied with a big four-run bottom of the seventh inning to overcome a 6-3 deficit and go in front 7-6. Junior closer James Stone, who came on at the start of the eighth inning, would get the first two batters out to begin the ninth before back-to-back singles by Carthage put the possible go-ahead run on base. Stone, however, got the next batter to hit a grounder to first base and he covered first and took the toss from Ryan Scheetz for the final out and send the team into a frenzy around the pitcher’s mound. BVU earned the program’s first trip to the World Series since the 1968 team advanced into what was then the NAIA World Series.