NWU got a 42-yard touchdown run from quarterback Keaton Erdmann and also a 16-yard touchdown pass to lead 14-0 with 3:11 remaining in the opening quarter. BVU got on the board with 24 seconds left on a 24-yard touchdown strike from Garcia to Dennis to make it 14-7.
Garcia and Messerly hooked up in the end zone for a 13-yard touchdown which tied the game at 14-14 five minutes into the second quarter. Erdmann would again keep the ball and ran nearly untouched 22 yards to put the Prairie Wolves back in front before Garcia and Messarly connected for the second time in the game from 13 yards out and tied things back up at 21-21 with 1:56 on the clock. NWU drove down the field and set up for a potential go-ahead 29-yard field goal as time expired in the half, but the ball bounced off the right upright and the attempt was no good.
Nebraska Wesleyan turned the ball over on downs to begin the second half, but the Beavers managed only 12 yards in five plays and forced to punt. NWU took advantage and went back down the field 52 yards in just six plays for the only scoring of the third quarter.
The Beavers turned the ball over on their next two drives with an interception and on downs, and Nebraska Wesleyan was able to capitalize on the second of those with a three-yard run that made it 35-21 just 30 seconds into the fourth. The Prairie Wolves tacked on another score with a 10-yard touchdown run with under six minutes to go.
Senior tight end Gavin Honkomp hauled in a touchdown pass in his final career game to pull BVU back within two touchdowns but NWU again made it a three-score game with a field goal that made it 45-28. Garcia's final touchdown pass came to Dennis from eight yards out with 38 seconds for the game's final score.
NWU (2-8, 2-5 A-R-C) finished with 327 yards rushing and five touchdowns while averaging 6.2 yards per carry.
Senior Bobby Gross capped his career with 18 total tackles while fellow senior Drew Volkmann added 12 tackles and a big interception early in the game on a double reverse pass by NWU.
Buena Vista ends the year at 2-8 overall (1-6 A-R-C). The game was the final in the career of 11 seniors and one student coach.