Sophomore Johnny Messerly hauled in a big 87-yard touchdown reception to cap the scoring with just under 50 seconds remaining in the game. The score came on the first play after a booming 70-yard punt from Duhawks. Messerly finished with a team-high six receptions on the day for 163 yards and the touchdown.
Garcia took over for starter Zy Gravitt at the start of the second half and completed 12-of-20 for 200 yards and the two touchdowns. Gravitt was 4-of-14 in the opening half for 45 yards and was intercepted three times.
Junior Adriel Fussell led the Beavers in rushing with 70 yards on 12 carries as the team finished with under 100 yards (99) for the first time since the season opener.
The Duhawks (2-5, 2-3 A-R-C) came into the game ranked second in the A-R-C during conference play in passing yards per game. Quarterback Jacob Richtman finished 24-of-43 for 276 yards and two touchdowns. Brock Couch hauled in five catches for 102 yards.
Senior Keaton Bindel registered a season-high 10 tackles to lead the way defensively for BVU, including six tackles for a loss. Junior Brody Boeckman was next with six tackles as was Noah Delgado. Senior Matthew Beisswenger had four stops and four pass breakups.
Buena Vista drops to 2-5 overall (1-4 A-R-C) and will be back on the road next Saturday at No. 14 Central College. Kickoff in Pella is at 1 p.m.