As the shot found the bottom of net, fans threw rolls of toilet paper into the air, cheering as they streamed to the tartan surface of Siebens Fieldhouse. The new scoring champ hugged her teammates, Coach Naughton, her mother, Delphine Demers, and her four siblings, including Joleen (Demers) Brown ’84, who was a senior basketball starter when Jeannie teamed with her in the backcourt as a freshman.
“My dad, Louis Demers Jr., died on Feb. 26, 1986,” she remembers. “He was always with me in spirit.”
Henningsen said she came to BV because she had the opportunity to play both softball and basketball. The University of Iowa had recruited her to play softball, only.
As a freshman, she played third base on the Beavers’ 1984 NCAA Division III National Championship team. She would go on to earn all-league honors and All-American laurels in both sports. She was a four-time First Team All-Iowa Conference honoree in basketball and a three-time first-teamer in softball.
“I had two of the greatest coaches I could ever have in Coach Marge Willadsen and Coach Naughton,” she says. “They put together very competitive teams and remained friends and mentors of mine long after college.”
Four or five basketball teammates would finish the season each February or March, then join the softball team for practice. And while seasons overlapped, the coaches were accommodating when it came to sharing players who wanted to experience the challenges and thrills of being a dual-sport student-athlete.
Beyond her siblings who graduated from BV, Jeannie’s husband, Mark Henningsen, was also a Beaver, having graduated in 1987. The couple’s children, Jordan and Jalen, were student-athletes at BVU as well, graduating in 2015 and 2017, respectively.
After graduating, Henningsen taught and coached in the Storm Lake Community School District. When Mark’s sales career took the couple to Omaha for three years, Jeannie was an at-home parent with their young children. She returned to the classroom when they relocated back to Storm Lake in 1998. She taught third grade for 17 years at Alta-Aurelia, then became an Elementary/Middle School Principal and has served in that capacity for nine rewarding years.
Henningsen also coached throughout her career, having achieved a milestone in earning her 500th victory as a head volleyball coach at Alta-Aurelia in 2022. In addition, she coached golf, girls’ basketball, softball, and little league baseball through the years.
Baseball, she says, gave her a jumpstart into organized athletics. Well, baseball and life on the farm near Truesdale, a few miles northeast of Storm Lake.
“Growing up on the farm, my siblings and I played sports year-round with each other,” she says. “I was then fortunate enough to be able to play little league baseball with the boys at Truesdale from third grade to seventh grade. We didn’t have organized sports exclusive for girls at the time, so I was allowed to play on the boys’ teams. Despite not playing girls’ softball early in my life, softball became my favorite sport.”
It was a BV softball teammate, in fact, who gave Henningsen the idea to meet Woodard that afternoon at Carver-Hawkeye Arena in Iowa City. “Mark and I arrived early for ESPN’s GameDay telecast, and we were watching the production,” she says. “And then I noticed that Jill Petsel (a 1985 BV graduate) was courtside and had her photo taken with Lynette Woodard. It was a great opportunity, so I asked security personnel if I could do the same.”